How to Reheat Papa John’s Pizza: A Step-by-Step Guide

Most Papa John’s customers purchase a size larger in case of any leftovers. They notice that warmed leftover pizza differs from Papa John’s delivery service.

Yet, reheated pizza is equivalent to the scent and texture of fresh-out-of-the-oven pizza. Continue reading to learn to reheat Papa John’s pizza to taste as close to the original version.

How To Reheat Papa John's Pizza

Can You Reheat Papa John’s Pizza?

Papa John’s is one of the few pizza businesses with reheating guidelines on the box. This action is very appreciated by all consumers, especially since the directions are visible.

Can You Reheat Papa John's Pizza?

Reheating Papa John’s pizza for up to 4 days is okay when you’ve already brought it if it’s been kept in the refrigerator. The most serious safety hazard is meat pizzas.

If meat is not fully warmed, harmful germs can grow. Reheat only meat-topped Papa John’s Pizza refrigerated for 2 days. Even so, make certain that the meat is scorching hot before serving.

How To Reheat Papa John’s Pizza

In The Oven

Reheat pizza in the oven

Using a range to reheat your pizza may take longer than other cooking methods, but you will finish with flawlessly cooked pizza pieces.

Step 1: Preheating the oven to 320ºC

It will help if you let the oven fully heat up before reheating your delicious pizza. The last point you desire is for the pizza to heat up gradually.

Step 2: Prepare a baking sheet with aluminum foil.

You need to line a baking sheet with foil or use this pizza pan and bake for a few minutes. The goal is to have the plate and foil hot before they touch the pizza.

Step 3: Baking the pizza.

Remove the heated tray with care and lay the pizza on it. Return the tray to the oven for about 10 minutes, examining it now and then to ensure it does not burn. The finished product should be a hot, flavorful, and crispy slice.

Step 4: Enjoying

The final step is to take the pizza from the oven and set it aside for 2 minutes before eating it.

In The Microwave

Step 1: Prepare a microwave-safe dish

This dish will not only prevent your dinner from spilling on the floor. It’ll additionally protect you from any major injuries caused by hot food or microwaved plates bursting.

Step 2: Place an oven towel over the dish.

While reheating leftovers in the microwave, another technique to protect yourself is to use an oven towel.

Step 3: When reheating leftover pizza, use low power.

The less power, the better. Because the additional radiation from high-powered microwaves increases the likelihood of your slice being dry or burned.

Step 4: After warming, separate the toppings from the cheese and sauce.

Toppings like pepperoni, bacon, and onion may heat up much faster than the rest of your pizza slice.

Step 5: After warming, set aside for 2 minutes.

Let the leftover warmth in the pizza complete the cooking process. It will also assist in replenishing some of the moisture lost while microwaving meals.

Step 6: Enjoying

The final step is to take the pizza from the microwave and set it aside for some minutes before consuming it.

Reheating pizza in your microwave

Reheating pizza in the microwave will result in a soggy, greasy, and chewy crust. Therefore, this method is not recommended for enjoying your leftover pizza.

How Long To Reheat Papa John’s Pizza?

In a prepared oven, Papa John’s Pizza can be warmed in 10 minutes, the same time it takes to reheat the pizza in a toaster oven.

In contrast, reheating pizza in the microwave is faster. It lasts for a few seconds at a time.

The time required to microwave a pizza depends on its size, the number of slices, and whether it has been frozen. A small, unfrozen pizza will take around 2-3 minutes to microwave, while a big, frozen pizza will take 6-8 minutes to microwave.

Tips And Tricks On Reheating Papa John’s Pizza

Tips And Tricks On Reheating Papa John's Pizza

Following are a few pointers to assist you in reheating the leftover pizza:

The first step is to set aside a safe temperature. Always keep the leftover pizza in the refrigerator. Remove your pizza from the fridge and let it come to room temperature. This action keeps the pizza from becoming too mushy when reheated.

Second, use an oven. If you choose to reheat the Papa John’s Pizza in the oven, you will surely obtain that crispy pizza crust.

Finally, double-check the toppings. To destroy germs, microwave a meat pizza until it is scorching hot.


How Long Does Leftover Papa John’s Last?

Leftover Papa John’s pizza lasts 3 to 4 days in the refrigerator. To extend the shelf life of leftover pizza, place it in hermetically sealed containers or large freezer bags and wrap it tightly with large tin foil or a freezer cover.

If the pizza has been sitting at room temperature for too long, it may not be as delicious as it should be. If your pizza has been left out for more than two hours, consuming it is no longer permissible.

Which Temperature Is Needed When Reheating Papa John’s Pizza Safely?

For the best results, reheat Papa John’s Pizza at 320 degrees Celsius in a preheated oven. If you use a microwave, the temperature will be around 250 degrees Celsius. As a result, you must ensure that the pizza does not get too dry.


You now know how to correctly reheat Papa John’s pizza in two kitchen facilities. You may eat your favorite cuisine at any time of day with a few easy steps along with some patience.

Hopefully, these pizza hacks have given you new information to make those leftover slices taste better next time.